The Daily Misanthrope

October 30, 2026  •  Misanthrope Index: 8.3 — Approaching Walken

Folly of the Day

Two Solicitors Routed Their Own Client's £11m Claim Through a Company They Each Owned About Eleven Per Cent Of. The Rule They Were Working Around Was Laid Down in 1784, and the Court Held That the Working-Around Was Itself the Proof.

An oil portrait of about 1690 by Richard van Bleeck showing the lawyer and archivist William Petyt in dark robes, holding a rolled copy of Magna Carta.
Richard van Bleeck via Wikimedia Commons / public domain

Eleven per cent is a confession with a decimal point in it. A man who believed the rule meant what it said would never have needed to work out how little of a company he could own and still collect, and the arithmetic is the evidence against him: two centuries of law treated as a shape to be fitted around rather than a thing to be obeyed. The oldest vanity in the profession is not greed but cleverness — the certainty that a prohibition written by lesser men in 1784 cannot possibly have anticipated you.

Source: Legal Futures

The Wire

Their Solicitors Issued the Claim Form in Time and Then Failed to Serve It Before the Cut-Off. Five Thousand Clients Are Now Stayed Out of the Action and Owe About £972,000 Towards the Costs of a Trial They Cannot Take Part In.

The Gothic revival facade of the Royal Courts of Justice on the Strand in London, seat of the High Court of England and Wales, photographed from across the road in daylight.
David Castor via Wikimedia Commons / CC0

An entire profession exists to do things by dates, and here is a firm that did everything except the date. The clients are the ones holding the bill, which is the arrangement the law has always quietly made: a solicitor's diary is a private matter right up to the moment it becomes five thousand other people's money.

Source: Legal Futures

The Wire

The Regulator Has Been Reviewing Its Own Dishonesty Cases and Withdrawing Them, Sometimes Days Before the Hearing. Its Own Figures Show One in Five Contested Cases Ended in No Finding at All, While Enforcement Cost £28.5 Million.

A regulator that discovers at the courtroom door that it cannot prove dishonesty is a regulator that had been alleging dishonesty on the strength of something other than proof, and doing it with a straight face and a press office. The £28.5 million is not quite the scandal. The scandal is how much of it bought nothing but the word.

Source: Legal Futures

Daily misanthropy by email — free.
The day's worst decisions, curated every morning, in your inbox by breakfast.

No algorithms. No engagement bait. Just the view from the abyss.

The Wire

The Average Bar Course Now Costs £17,600. Forty-One Per Cent of British Students Who Sit It Have Pupillage Five Years Later. At One Provider the Figure Is Eleven Per Cent, and the Regulator's Contribution Is to Advise Students to Be Realistic.

A late nineteenth-century pen-and-ink engraving by Herbert Railton of the Inner Temple Library in London, showing tall bookcases, arched windows and reading desks in an empty panelled hall.
Herbert Railton via Wikimedia Commons / public domain

The body that accredits the courses has advised the customer to be realistic about the product it accredits, and has now commissioned a review to establish whether the thing it has been approving for years was ever fit for purpose. Somebody is selling £17,600 of hope at eleven per cent, and the regulator's considered intervention is to suggest the buyer think harder about it.

Source: Legal Futures / Bar Standards Board

The Wire

The Ministry of Justice Says It Cannot Afford an Above-Inflation Pay Rise for Judges. It Has Offered Them Interest-Free Season Ticket Loans Instead, and Pointed Out That They Already Have a Cycle-to-Work Scheme.

When an institution cannot give you money it gives you a scheme, and the scheme is always announced in the voice of a gift. The cycle-to-work reminder is the detail that earns the item: somebody drafted that clause, read it back to himself, and let it go out to the High Court bench having found nothing in it to regret.

Source: The Law Society Gazette

The Wire

The Civil Justice Council Has Recommended That a Witness Should Have to Declare, in Writing, That the Account of His Own Life Was Not Generated by a Machine.

We have arrived at the place where a man must certify that his own recollection is his own. The declaration is no insult to the witness; it is an admission about everybody else, and about a profession that has spent two years discovering how many of its documents nobody actually wrote.

Source: Legal Futures / Civil Justice Council

The Wire

The Retiring Master of the Rolls Will Keep Two of His Taskforces. He Told a Roomful of Technologists That Retirement Will Not Be Completely Retirement, and Floated an Intergalactic Taskforce.

A man does not retire from an office; he retires from being consulted, and that is the part nobody has ever managed to give up. The intergalactic joke lands because it is only barely one — the instinct it parodies is the same instinct that keeps two taskforces warm on the way out of the door, against the terrible possibility of a morning in which nobody requires a view.

Source: The Law Society Gazette

The Wire

The Agency Spent $7.8 Million on a Tool to Detect Sensitive Files Being Shared With Everybody. The Tool Was Never Told to Look for the Words 'For Official Use Only'. One Third of the Exposed Files Said Exactly That.

A tool bought to notice what must not be shared, never instructed to notice the words that mark a document secret, unreviewed for nine years by people who no longer work there — this is not a safeguard that failed, it is an institution that bought the sensation of having one and declined, for a decade, to ask whether anything behind it was switched on.

Source: GSA Office of Inspector General / FedScoop

The Wire

He Filed a Petition the Court Had Already Dismissed, Was Warned From the Bench Not to Argue It, Argued It Anyway, and Was Fined 1 Lakh. The Fine Was Then Waived Because He Is an Advocate of That Court.

The costs were remitted on the one ground that ought to have doubled them: he is an officer of that court, which is precisely why he knew the question had been answered before he rose to ask it again — professional courtesy, extended far enough, becomes a certificate of impunity issued to the only man in the room with no excuse.

Source: LiveLaw

The Wire

In 2013 Shared Services Canada Set Out to Modernise More Than 220 Federal Call Centres. By 2020 It Had Onboarded Eight, at a Cost of $52 Million — Three Times the Estimate for the Whole Programme — and Then Cut Features to Stay Within Budget.

Eight call centres out of two hundred and twenty, at six and a half million dollars apiece, by a department that had already tripled its estimate and responded by removing the features it had bought — and which then declined to check the invoices, having established that it could not be trusted with the arithmetic in the first place.

Source: Office of the Auditor General of Canada

Black-Robed Egomania

She Promised Senior Judges the Judgments Would Be Circulated by the End of June 2025, and Was Given Work Outside London on the Strength of It. Three Still Were Not Written When She Was Reprimanded This Week — and She Argued the Delay Was Not Misconduct.

The defence entered here — too much work, too little time, the backlog accumulated — is the precise plea a judge spends a career declining to accept from the people standing in front of her, where it goes by the name of missing a deadline and carries costs. But note what the file actually records: not a woman overwhelmed, but a woman believed. Colleagues moved her workload on the strength of a date she gave them, and the date turned out to be the cheapest thing she had to give.

Source: Legal Futures / Judicial Conduct Investigations Office

The Siren Ledger

A Fraud Ring Used a Woman Who Did Not Exist to Take His Money. He Then Went to Work for Them, Moving Millions Through His Own Accounts — and Carried On After FBI Agents Sat Him Down and Told Him the Money Was Stolen.

The delusion was never that he fell for a woman who did not exist — anyone can be lied to once. It was the conclusion he drew afterwards: that having been shown the inside of the machine he was now operating it rather than still inside it, a belief he maintained while federal agents explained to his face that the money was stolen, and which he defended with invoices he wrote himself.

Source: US Attorney's Office, Eastern District of Pennsylvania / MyChesCo

From the library — 27 special editions

More Scandalous Authors: Mad, Bad, and Dangerous to Read, Vol. IIThe private conduct of literature's great names, continued — the debtors, deserters, duelists, and one… When Settled Science Was Wrong: Eight Confident CatastrophesThe expert consensus of its day — confident, credentialed, peer-approved, and catastrophically wrong. Artists Behaving Badly: 13 Great Painters Who Were MonstersFrom Cellini's dagger to Picasso's queue of the heartbroken — five centuries of immortal art made by men…

Browse all special editions →

Daily misanthropy by email — free.
The day's worst decisions, curated every morning, in your inbox by breakfast.

No algorithms. No engagement bait. Just the view from the abyss.

Today's edition  ·  Special editions  ·  Archive  ·  Submit a tip