The Daily Misanthrope

October 29, 2026  •  Misanthrope Index: 8.6 — Deep Walken

Folly of the Day

In 2022 Indiana Disbarred Him for Forging a Judge's Signature on a Court Order. The Court Wrote Down What He Had Done, Under His Name, For Ever. He Is Now Charged With Collecting a Fee and Faking the Filing.

The Indiana Statehouse in Indianapolis photographed at night, its limestone dome and portico lit from below. The building houses the Indiana Supreme Court, which ordered the disbarment.
Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0

A forger's trade depends on the mark never asking the body that holds the real record, and he chose — twice — a trade where the record is a court docket: permanent, free to search, and kept by the very institution being deceived. He signed a judge's name to an order whose only purpose was to be filed with the court that would know it had never issued it. The arrogance is not the forgery. It is the belief that a court might fail to recognize its own orders, and then the belief, four years later, that a man whose own record is the first thing anyone would find could go back to a business whose entire substance is the examination of records. The defense raises a question of its own: what was a disbarred man doing with a paralegal, a client, and a fee?

Source: Indiana Supreme Court, Case No. 21S-DI-16 (21 April 2022); 2026 charges reported by the ABA Journal

The Wire

The Mayor Says Large Chunks of the $435,000 Staffing Report Were Written by AI. It Counted Empty Desks as People, Costed Part-Timers as Full-Timers, and Assumed Any Job With 'Project' in the Title Was a Duplicate.

The Wellington waterfront and central business district at night, office towers lit along the harbour with hills rising behind.
Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 3.0 (Donovan Govan)

An efficiency review is a document whose only product is its own rigour, which makes a padded one not merely wrong but self-refuting: the firm engaged to identify 330 surplus people could not correctly count the people the council already had. It charged $435,000 to report that a workforce was larger than the work required, and the mayor's account is that large parts of that work were done by a machine. The first thing shown to be surplus to requirements was the counting.

Source: RNZ / Local Democracy Reporting

The Wire

The High Court Directed the Director General of Prisons to Swear the Compliance Affidavit Himself. He Had a Subordinate Swear It, and It Was Incomplete. He Now Has a Contempt Notice.

An instruction to attend to something personally is the single direction that cannot be delegated, because the personal attention is the whole of what was ordered; sending a junior to swear it is not compliance but a demonstration of precisely the attitude complained of. Asked to account for a delay, the office produced, in its own hand and on the record, fresh evidence of the cause.

Source: LiveLaw

Daily misanthropy by email — free.
The day's worst decisions, curated every morning, in your inbox by breakfast.

No algorithms. No engagement bait. Just the view from the abyss.

The Wire

The High Court Ordered Punjab to Pay the Dearness Allowance It Owed Its Own Staff. The Man Who Runs the State Did Not. Costs of ₹1 Lakh, an Affidavit to Explain Himself, and an Order to Attend in Person.

The assurance was offered to a court that can call for the registry's file, and the registry's file was the very thing the assurance described — so the one reader he needed to satisfy was the one reader certain to look. Officialdom's besetting error is to mistake a tribunal for an audience when it is an auditor.

Source: LiveLaw

The Wire

The Advert Said: Find a Lower Price and We'll Match It. The Match Applied Only If the Cheaper Ticket Came From a Trade-Body Member — a Condition the Advert Omitted and the Website Kept Two Clicks Away.

A promise written to be believed and drafted to be unenforceable is not a promise but an advertisement for one. The defence refutes itself with admirable economy: if the condition excluded almost nobody, there was room to say so; if there was no room to say so, it excluded somebody.

Source: Advertising Standards Authority (ruling on Attraction Tickets Ltd, 28 October 2026)

The Wire

The Waste Dumped in Smithy Street Contained Packaging With His Name and Address On It. He Ignored the Council's Notices, Did Not Turn Up at Court, and Blamed His Cleaner. The £80 Fine Came With £1,082 of Costs.

A general view of fly-tipped household waste and bin bags left at the edge of a wooded lane in Essex. Illustrative photograph, not the Haslingden scene.
Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0

The animal fouls its own nest and then leaves a calling card in it. Note the arithmetic of the sentence: the dumping was worth £80 and the eleven months of ignored letters were worth £1,082, which is the court pricing the contempt rather than the rubbish. He was not undone by surveillance or forensic science but by the ordinary act of reading an address label — and his answer was that somebody else ought to have read it for him.

Source: Lancashire Telegraph

The Wire

Their Brief Cited Cases That Did Not Exist. They Said It Was Typing Errors — and Went On Saying So Through the Motion to Correct, Oral Argument and the Show-Cause Response. The Court Said an Apology at the First Opportunity Would Have Cost Them Far Less.

A wooden gavel resting on its sound block on a desk beside a stack of papers.
Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 2.0 (Blogtrepreneur)

The fabrications were a failure of diligence and survivable as such; what cost them six months was electing to defend the fabrications in front of the only readers in the country professionally equipped to check them. Every lawyer knows the cover-up is worse than the offence — a thing known in the abstract by all of them, and discovered in the particular by these two.

Source: ABA Journal, reporting the Ninth Circuit opinion of 3 June 2026

The Wire

Claims to the Workplace Tribunal Rose Twenty-Two Per Cent in a Year, to a Record 53,666. Its President Says the Cause Is No Longer the Labour Market, Which Has Stopped Predicting Anything, but the Arrival of Generative AI.

A printed legal document on a desk with a pen resting on the signature line, lit in warm tones.
Blogtrepreneur / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY 2.0

A grievance used to cost something to lodge: an afternoon, a blank page, and the slow discovery somewhere down it that one did not actually have a case. That cost was never a defect in the machinery, it was the machinery — the only filter the tribunal ever owned, and the cheapest one it will ever be offered. Abolish the effort of composing a complaint and you find out what the queue was always made of.

Source: Fair Work Commission Annual Report 2025-26, reported by Human Resources Director (28 October 2026)

The Wire

The Not-for-Profit Took $2.2 Billion of Public Money and Paid Its Departing Chief Executive Nearly $6 Million, Including a $2.4 Million Bonus. It Also Employs His Brother and His Son. The Board Says Its Oversight of Executive Pay Is Rigorous.

“Not-for-profit” describes a tax status, not a standard of living: no shareholder draws a dividend and six million dollars still walks out of the building. The board's defence is the tell — that its oversight of executive pay is rigorous is the one proposition the figure has already decided, since rigour is not what would have prevented a number like that, it is the process that produced it and then put its name to it.

Source: The Center Square, citing Mitre Corp.'s federal tax filings (29 October 2026)

Black-Robed Egomania

She Contacted Another Court About the Arraignment of a Friend of Her Sister's, Asked That Bail Be Set, and Invoked Her Judicial Title Repeatedly While Doing It. The Judge She Contacted Recused Himself.

The title is the one asset a judge is handed and the one she may never spend, since its entire value consists in nobody being able to buy anything with it. She appears to have thought the governing distinction was that the favour was not for herself — but an office is not a favour bank that becomes one when the favour is for a friend of a relation. The judge at the other end grasped the point in the time it took to hear it, which is why he stepped off the case; the mitigation, and it is real, is that she eventually grasped it too and turned herself in.

Source: New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct, In the Matter of Karle (determination of 13 October 2026), reported by FingerLakes1

From the library — 27 special editions

Famous Authors’ Scandalous Private Lives: Mad, Bad, and Dangerous to ReadThe abominable private conduct of literature's and art's great names — the murderers, deadbeats, eccentrics,… Scholars Behaving Badly: The Greatest Academic Frauds in HistoryA century of professors, presidents and prize-winners caught manufacturing the very evidence they demanded… Business Blunders: Titans Who Confidently Declined the FutureTitans of industry, at the height of their power, confidently declining the future as it walked through the…

Browse all special editions →

Daily misanthropy by email — free.
The day's worst decisions, curated every morning, in your inbox by breakfast.

No algorithms. No engagement bait. Just the view from the abyss.

Today's edition  ·  Special editions  ·  Archive  ·  Submit a tip