The Daily Misanthrope

November 12, 2026  •  Misanthrope Index: 8.5 — Approaching Walken

Folly of the Day

For Twelve Years He Told the Courts He Lacked Capacity and Needed Round-the-Clock Care. Surveillance Filmed Him at the Gym, and Then in a Go-Kart Competition. The Devoted Volunteer Carer From His Church Turned Out to Be His Wife.

A single-seat racing go-kart with an exposed engine and roll bar, parked on a kart circuit.
Syced / Wikimedia Commons / CC0

A lie told once is a lie; a lie told for twelve years is a second life, and this one had to be furnished. Note what the fabrication actually cost him, quite apart from the costs order: to be a man without capacity he had to keep a wife offstage for twelve years and three children out of the account entirely, and to recast his own marriage as the charity of a stranger from church. The judge put it exactly — the destruction of a life would be tragic and the devotion would be inspiring, if any of it were true. What ended it was not a detective. It was an hour at the gym and a go-kart, which is to say an ordinary afternoon; a man who had successfully simulated ruin to doctors, experts and the Administrative Court could not simulate it on a Saturday when nobody was watching. The arrogance is not in the scheme but in its duration. He had twelve years in which to notice that the story was better than his life and had become more expensive than it.

Source: Legal Futures

The Wire

The Charity Was Founded to Bring Private Prosecutions Against Animal Cruelty. Two Crown Court Judges Found Its Prosecutions Were Improper, Evidentially Deficient and Should Never Have Been Brought — and One of Them Reported It to the Regulator Himself.

The private prosecution is the law's standing compliment to the citizen: a presumption that an ordinary person, confronted with wrongdoing the state has overlooked, can be trusted with the machinery for a while. This is what the compliment costs when it is accepted by people who mistake conviction for competence. They had the correct enemy — cruelty to animals is cruelty — and they went to court so badly that two judges had to say so in writing and one of them wrote to the regulator unprompted, which is the judicial equivalent of a man leaving the theatre to find a policeman. The trustee who attended a single meeting is the structural point. Oversight is not a name on a form; it is the only thing standing between a cause and the people running it, and a board that cannot be bothered has not delegated its judgment, it has abolished it.

Source: The Charity Commission

The Wire

He Had Been at the Ministry a Fortnight When He Was Charged. It Suspended Him on Full Pay and Left Him There for Five Years — More Than $500,000 — Because Nobody Was Willing to Make the Decision.

Five years is not an oversight; it is a policy nobody had to write down. What the review has actually found is the mechanism by which a large organisation converts cowardice into procedure: obtain advice that counsels delay, decline to test it, and thereafter every month of inaction is compliance rather than failure. Observe that the Ministry was not afraid of Harrison. It was afraid of appearing in its own courts as a litigant and being found to have erred — which is to say that the department responsible for the administration of justice in New Zealand priced its own reputation for legal correctness at half a million dollars of public money, and paid. The Commission is right that not deciding was the worst decision available. It was also the only one that could never be attributed to anybody, which is precisely why it won.

Source: 1News / RNZ

Daily misanthropy by email — free.
The day's worst decisions, curated every morning, in your inbox by breakfast.

No algorithms. No engagement bait. Just the view from the abyss.

The Wire

He Ran the Hospital's Sterile Supply Department and Took $258,000 From Its Suppliers. One Supplier's Sales to the Health Board Rose From $52,000 a Year to $400,000. He Signed Off 217 of Its Invoices Himself.

The detail that convicts him is not the money but the arithmetic he left behind: a supplier's revenue multiplying almost eightfold in the years one man was approving its paper, and that man approving two invoices in every three. He did not hide the pattern, because he did not believe anybody would ever lay the two columns side by side — the characteristic faith of the middle manager, who knows better than anyone how little of what he does is ever read. Note the thirty-nine-thousand-dollar invoice for a five-thousand-dollar order, approved by the man who helped place it and paid twenty-two thousand for the favour. That is not greed outrunning sense; it is greed that has correctly observed, over nine years, that sense was never going to be applied. He was wrong by one audit, and he answered the question by failing to come home from a holiday.

Source: 1News

The Wire

The Authority Handed the Royal Commission an Executive's Notebook With Every Single Page Blacked Out. On the Morning of the Hearing, Compelled, It Produced a Version You Could Read.

A declassified government document with most of its text obscured by thick black redaction bars.
Central Intelligence Agency / Wikimedia Commons / public domain

A page redacted in part is a claim of privilege. Every page redacted is an argument that the notebook itself is a state secret, and no institution advances that argument about a notebook unless it has read the notebook. The authority has therefore managed the one outcome worse than disclosure: it has told the commission, in the most emphatic format available, that there is something here, and then produced it anyway a few hours later when asked twice. Note that the readable version appeared on the morning of the hearing — not after reflection, not after legal advice, but after compulsion, which means the redaction was never a legal position at all, merely a hope. The Commissioner's advice to the public service of Victoria was 'if in doubt send it out'. That a royal commission into construction corruption has had to issue, as guidance, an instruction a competent adult would call candour, is the finding.

Source: ABC News (Australia)

The Wire

The State Needs Ten Square Metres to Finish a Railway Upgrade. The Strip Is Sixteen Metres Long and Sixty Centimetres Wide, the Last Owner Was a Swedish Soft-Drink Maker Who Died Over a Century Ago, and Written Objections Close on 17 November.

The platform and station buildings at Beenleigh railway station in Queensland, Australia, on an overcast day.
TravellerQLD / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 3.0

Sixty centimetres wide. Not a field, not a yard — a ribbon of Queensland too narrow to put a shed on, carrying a title that has outlived its owner, his eleven children, his brewery, his soda works and the marble-stoppered bottles children smashed to get at the marbles. The state does not want it for anything a nineteenth-century businessman would recognise as a use; it wants it so that a railway can be made faster, and it cannot have it until it has formally invited a dead man's heirs to object in writing by a Tuesday. One is tempted to call this absurd, and it is, but notice what the absurdity is made of. The thing that has survived a hundred and twenty years here is not the man, the business, the bottles or the family — all gone, bar a street sign. It is the paperwork. Property is the most durable thing we make, and we make it out of nothing but agreement to keep a record.

Source: ABC News (Australia)

The Wire

Misconduct Reports Rose Forty-Five Per Cent to 16,499, Which the Regulator Calls Unsustainable. So It Has Raised the Threshold for Acting on a Complaint, Charged Every Solicitor Another £50 to Raise £25m, and Will 'Explore Alternative Regulatory Tools' It Declines to Name.

Read the two halves together and the arithmetic is unanswerable: complaints up by nearly half, and the response is to make it harder to lodge one that counts, paid for by a levy on the complained-about. Every clause is defensible on its own and the sum is a regulator contracting under load while describing the contraction as strategy. The tell is the phrase 'alternative regulatory tools', which appears in a published plan without a single example — because an alternative to investigating a solicitor, when named out loud, turns out to be a conversation. There is a real and respectable argument that enforcement is a crude instrument and early supervision prevents more harm. It is simply not the argument that is being made here, because the thing being promised is not supervision of all the firms that need it; the chief executive has said so. What is being funded is a smaller number of cases and ten million pounds of reserves.

Source: Legal Futures

The Wire

He Lost the Trade Mark Case on a Finding of Bad Faith. Instead of Appealing He Brought Three More Sets of Proceedings — Suing the Other Side's Barrister, Then Their Solicitors for £375,000. The Judge Certified It Totally Without Merit.

The Gothic stone facade of the Royal Courts of Justice on the Strand in London, seen from the street.
Wikimedia Commons / CC0

There is a species of pride that cannot distinguish between losing an argument and being wronged, and it is the most expensive condition in English law because the courts will keep giving it hearings. Look at the shape of the thing. He did not appeal the finding against him, which is the one route that could have changed it; he sued the barrister, then the solicitors, then asked a third time to redraft the claim against the solicitors. Each step moves further from the decision he objects to and closer to the people who merely argued it, which is the unmistakable signature of a man who has stopped trying to win and started trying to be answered. He was already under a restraint order. That is the court having told him, formally and in advance, that this is what he does — and the telling, like everything else, was filed and read and found to be about somebody else.

Source: Legal Futures

Black-Robed Egomania

A Barrister Posted a Video Mocking the Portraits of Old Judges. He Summoned Her to a Docket of Thirty-Two Cases, Asked Where She Went to Law School and Suggested She Seek a Refund, Then Handed Her an Order — Already Signed — Calling Her 'Extraordinarily Arrogant'.

The word is in his own order. A judge who sits down to compose a document about a thirty-second video and reaches, in one sentence, for childish, unprofessional, disrespectful, belligerent, immature and extraordinarily arrogant has not described the video; he has described the temperature of the room he was sitting in, and then signed it. Every escalation here is an escalation of audience. He could have spoken to her privately; he summoned her before thirty-two cases' worth of lawyers. He could have written to her; he filed it in a criminal matter so her client got a copy. He could have left it there; he had it pinned at the security desks of two courthouses and posted to fourteen recipients including the police. And the order was signed before she opened her mouth, which is the only fact in the file that is purely legal rather than merely human: a man whose office exists to hear first and decide second, doing it the other way round, about himself. The phones were on the tables in front of him the whole time. Nobody else's phone had been about him.

Source: Kentucky Judicial Conduct Commission

The Faithful

He Told the Wall Street Journal He Did Not Believe in Succession Planning, and Built a Company Where Sixty Executives Report to Him Alone. He Has Now Admitted an Affair With the Executive at the Centre of an Alleged Spy Plot — and the Times Reports a Second, With a Vice-President Who Also Reported to Him.

A man who declines to name a successor is not making a judgement about candidates; he is making one about mortality, and it is always the same judgement. Sixty direct reports and no chain beneath him is the organisational chart of that conviction drawn out in boxes — a structure in which nothing can happen without him, chosen by someone who could not imagine the sentence ending. And the same arithmetic produced the rest. The second relationship was with a woman who reported to him, which is the identical error in miniature: an estimate, repeatedly confirmed by thirty-three years of being right, that the ordinary rules governing the people below you are a description of them rather than of the arrangement. The company's statement is the purest specimen. It announced there was no reason to believe anything had been compromised before it had looked — a man so accustomed to his own certainty being sufficient that he let the press office use it as a finding of fact.

Source: ABC News (Australia)

From the library — 27 special editions

Neighbors Behaving Badly: The Greatest Spite Houses, Hedge Wars and Boundary FeudsThirteen feuds in which grown adults spent fortunes, decades and in one case two empires' worth of artillery… Political Stupidity: A Bipartisan Confederacy of DuncesOn political stupidity — the one truly bipartisan institution the republic has ever managed to build. Britain Behaving Badly: 22 Judges, Bosses and Regulators Caught by Their Own Records22 adjudicated British cases, drawn from the disciplinary registers nobody reads — and the one thing every…

Browse all special editions →

Daily misanthropy by email — free.
The day's worst decisions, curated every morning, in your inbox by breakfast.

No algorithms. No engagement bait. Just the view from the abyss.

Today's edition  ·  Special editions  ·  Archive  ·  Submit a tip