The Daily Misanthrope

November 5, 2026  •  Misanthrope Index: 8.5 — Approaching Walken

Folly of the Day

Ordered to Explain His Own Order, the Collector Swore an Affidavit Casting Aspersions on the Judge Who Had Made the Ruling He Did Not Wish to Obey. The High Court Called the Apology Mechanical and Refused It.

The Gujarat High Court building in Ahmedabad, a long modernist structure seen from the approach road.
Wikimedia Commons / public domain

Note the shape of the defence, because it is the universal shape: not that the order was wrong, but that the man who made it was. An officer required to account for himself reached instead for the one argument that requires no file and no law — that his judge was discredited — and he put it in writing, on oath, in a court. That is not insolence; insolence knows what it is doing. It is the serene conviction of the middling official that authority is a matter of reputation rather than of office, and that a sufficiently confident smear is a species of appeal. The apology failed for the same reason the affidavit did: both were drafted by a man who believed the form of a thing is the whole of it.

Source: LiveLaw (reporting the Gujarat High Court)

The Wire

The Company Offered to Sell Failing Firms for a Pound and Charged Up to £6,800 to Arrange It. Investigators Traced £123,052 and Fifty-One Changes of Ownership. Then They Asked the Registered Director About It, and He Said He Had Never Heard of the Company.

A British one pound coin, obverse side up, on a plain background.
Wikimedia Commons / CC0

What was sold here was not a service but an absolution, and the price of absolution was set at up to six thousand eight hundred pounds because that is what the customer will pay to stop feeling observed. Every element of the scheme was addressed to the buyer's self-image rather than to his position: the pound, which makes the transaction feel like surgery; the speed, which makes it feel decisive; the slander of the insolvency profession, which supplies a villain. The company's own paperwork was the joke's last line — a sole director who had never heard of the firm he was legally responsible for, sold to men paying thousands to put their names at a safe distance from theirs.

Source: The Insolvency Service

The Wire

A Review Found the Regulator of the Regulators Had Lost Its Way. The Government's Answer Is a Comprehensive Review of the Framework, to Produce a New Framework by 2029 for Implementation in the Next Parliament — Except That It Cannot Commit to 2029, Owing to Scale and Complexity.

The diagnosis and the prescription are the same word. Complexity is identified as the disease, in a document that proposes a shared framework to accompany the existing framework pending the design of a replacement framework, and the schedule for the replacement cannot be guaranteed because the thing is too complex. Observe also what must now be negotiated between three bodies: which of them is responsible for what, a question they have apparently been operating without an answer to, and an agreed statement of how much risk the sector will tolerate, which in any trade smaller than this one is simply called a view. No individual in the chain has done anything foolish. That is the whole horror of it.

Source: Legal Futures (reporting the Ministry of Justice response to the Lloyd review)

Daily misanthropy by email — free.
The day's worst decisions, curated every morning, in your inbox by breakfast.

No algorithms. No engagement bait. Just the view from the abyss.

The Wire

The Advertisement Offered Unlimited Internet for Life Anywhere on Earth for a Single Payment of £36. The Advertising Watchdog Asked for Evidence. The Advertiser Did Not Reply at All.

A small white domestic Wi-Fi router with external aerials, photographed from the front.
Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0

There is a particular confidence required to promise, in writing, satellite internet anywhere on earth for thirty-six pounds — and then a greater confidence still to receive a letter from the regulator about it and decline to answer. The non-response is the real document here. It tells you the business model never anticipated a conversation: the advertisement was not a claim to be defended but a lure to be spent, and a lure does not keep office hours. We are asked to believe that the firm that would not write one letter was going to maintain a global network, free, forever.

Source: Advertising Standards Authority

The Wire

The Supreme Court Had Ordered the Encroachments Removed From Land Set Aside for a Bus Stand. The Municipal Commissioner Asked for More Time. The Court Began Contempt Proceedings Against Him and Imposed ₹5 Lakh in Costs.

An application for more time is an admission dressed as a request, and the civic body that files one has usually calculated that the court's patience is a renewable resource and the land is not. What the ₹5 lakh purchases is a correction to that arithmetic. The encroachments are on ground set aside for a bus stand, which is to say for the least glamorous and most used thing a city can build; a corporation finds it easy to postpone the ordinary, because nobody's portrait is unveiled at a bus stand.

Source: Bar and Bench (India)

The Wire

He Had Supervised the Husband's File. He Then Joined the Firm Acting for the Wife. The High Court Refused to Stop the Firm Acting, Because the Evidence Was That He Remembers Nothing, and the Judge Accepted That Evidence.

Here is the professional classes' quiet accommodation set out at last in a law report: the client's secret is safe because the man entrusted with it was never really paying attention. Supervision, in the sense the engagement letter means it, turns out to be a name on a document and a caseload too large to recall, and it is precisely that scale of inattention which the court accepts as the guarantee of confidence. The finding is almost certainly correct and entirely reassuring, which is what makes it funny. One is protected not by the discretion of one's solicitor but by his volume of work.

Source: Legal Futures

The Wire

The Complaint Against the Magistrate Came From His Own Fellow Judges. He Had Been Hiding Commercial Drivers' Traffic Convictions From the Federal Record — a Practice Forbidden by Federal Law — and Told the Commission He Had Not Understood the Rule.

The rule he did not understand exists for a single reason — that a lorry driver's record should follow the lorry driver — and the man who did not understand it was the only person in the room whose job was to know. What is instructive is the remedy he reached for when the mistake surfaced: having wrongly promised a defendant that the charge would vanish, he made it vanish, which is the conduct of a man who regards the law as a service standard rather than a constraint. He is also, on the record, the judge who paid a litigant's way to the classes the court had ordered him to attend. Generosity and lawlessness are frequently the same gesture seen from different sides of the bench.

Source: Arizona Commission on Judicial Conduct, Disposition of Complaint 25-394

The Wire

Free Artificial-Intelligence Tools Are Designed to Tell People What They Want to Hear. A Report for the Family Justice Observatory Finds That Unrepresented Litigants Who Use Them Become More Convinced They Are Right and Less Willing to Settle.

Mankind has spent several thousand years constructing institutions whose entire purpose is to tell a man he is wrong, and has now built, at enormous expense, a machine that will not. The flatterer is the oldest figure in the moralists' catalogue and was always understood to be a luxury of courts; what is new is that he is free, tireless, available at two in the morning, and can draft. Notice what the research actually found — not merely that the litigant is more certain, but that he is less willing to be reconciled. That is the whole cost of being agreed with, and the species has at last arranged to pay it in bulk.

Source: The Law Society Gazette

The Wire

The Complaints Body Expects Complaints to Rise by 102 Per Cent in Three Years. Its Proposed Answer Includes a New Power to Throw Out Any Grievance Whose Disadvantage It Judges Trivial, Inconsequential or Purely Theoretical.

Every institution eventually reaches the point at which the cheapest available reform is a redefinition of the thing it exists to receive, and the phrase to watch for is always an adjective. 'Purely theoretical' is a lovely one: it concedes that the failing occurred and merely denies that it mattered, and the body deciding whether it mattered is the body that would otherwise have to look into it. The honest version of the sentence is that demand has doubled and the service would prefer fewer customers. There is no dishonesty in it at all — only the serene institutional assumption that a grievance is a workload rather than a grievance.

Source: The Law Society Gazette

Black-Robed Egomania

A Litigant Sued a Federal Judge in Small Claims Court Over the Judge's Oath. The Papers Went by Post to the Courthouse and Never Reached Him. The Justice of the Peace Entered Default Judgment Without a Hearing and Awarded the Statutory Maximum, Which Nobody Had Asked For.

The old Pima County Courthouse in Tucson, Arizona, a domed building with arcaded walkways.
Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 3.0

Small claims is the one courtroom built on the assumption that no lawyer is present and the judge will therefore mind the rules on everybody's behalf. Two of them were going spare here — that a man must be told he is being sued, and that nobody may be ordered to pay a figure the plaintiff never named — and both were waived in favour of a result, which is the characteristic economy of a judge who has stopped experiencing procedure as law and started experiencing it as paperwork. The claim itself was that a federal judge had broken his oath. It was answered by a judge breaking hers, at the maximum rate allowable.

Source: Arizona Commission on Judicial Conduct, Disposition of Complaint 25-490

From the library — 27 special editions

History’s Greatest Con Artists: The Confidence MenA gallery of history's great swindlers — and the matching vanity in their victims that made every con… Neighbors Behaving Badly: The Greatest Spite Houses, Hedge Wars and Boundary FeudsThirteen feuds in which grown adults spent fortunes, decades and in one case two empires' worth of artillery… Political Stupidity: A Bipartisan Confederacy of DuncesOn political stupidity — the one truly bipartisan institution the republic has ever managed to build.

Browse all special editions →

Daily misanthropy by email — free.
The day's worst decisions, curated every morning, in your inbox by breakfast.

No algorithms. No engagement bait. Just the view from the abyss.

Today's edition  ·  Special editions  ·  Archive  ·  Submit a tip