The Daily Misanthrope

October 23, 2026  •  Misanthrope Index: 8.4 — Approaching Walken

Folly of the Day

Leading Counsel's Fee for a Four-Day Appeal Was Two Million Pounds, Plus Twenty Thousand a Day for Turning Up, Plus a Hundred Thousand for a Hearing That Will Not Ordinarily Happen. Asked to Justify It, His Own Counsel Sensibly Declined to Try.

The Victorian Gothic stone frontage of the Royal Courts of Justice on the Strand in London, home of the Court of Appeal.
The wub / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0

The defence was not that the figure was right but that the man charging it was excellent and the market agreed — which is the oldest argument in the world and has never once been made by anyone who was being underpaid. A profession that bills by the hour has arrived at a fee for four days that no one in it will defend out loud, and it got there not by conspiracy but by each participant looking at the man beside him and concluding he was the modest one. The court's phrase for this is a yardstick with little relevance. The older phrase is a field of vision mistaken for a world.

Source: Legal Futures (reporting Lord Justice Fancourt's judgment, [2026] EWCA Civ 1353)

The Wire

The Firm Had a Whistleblowing Policy, Reporting Channels and a Published Framework. The Independent Review Found That Their Existence Did Not Make Them Effective, and the Commonwealth Has Now Extended Its Ban on New Contracts to February 2027.

Parliament House in Canberra photographed at dusk, seat of the Australian federal government, which has extended its suspension of new contracts with the firm.
JJ Harrison / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 3.0

An accounting firm exists to tell other organisations whether their controls work, and it was undone by owning a set of controls it had never once tested on itself. The reviewer's sentence is the finest thing written about modern institutional life this year: the firm had policies, and their existence did not make them effective. Everyone who has ever completed a mandatory module knows this and nobody says it. What the review actually describes is a body that read an allegation and asked only what it would cost to be told it was true.

Source: HRD Australia (reporting the Department of Finance independent review)

The Wire

The Regulator Assessed 966 Firms for Money-Laundering Compliance. Six of Them Did Not Have the Risk Assessment the Rules Have Required for More Than Nine Years.

Nine years is long enough to qualify as a solicitor twice over, and six firms spent it declining to write the single document that says what might go wrong. The regulator's gentler finding is the more damning one: the controls mostly exist and mostly do not work, because a form filled in is not a question asked. Eighteen per cent of files had the client's paperwork sitting in them unexamined — gathered, filed, never read. That is not laxity. That is a profession that has learned the shape of diligence without the substance, and cannot now tell the difference.

Source: Legal Futures (reporting the SRA AML annual report 2025-26)

Daily misanthropy by email — free.
The day's worst decisions, curated every morning, in your inbox by breakfast.

No algorithms. No engagement bait. Just the view from the abyss.

The Wire

He Told His Firm He Was Off Work Because He Was Unwell. He Had Been Arrested. Police Later Closed the Investigation With No Further Action — and the Lie He Told to Cover It Has Barred Him From the Profession.

The arrest came to nothing. The concealment of it ended a career that had not yet started. There is a particular kind of young confidence that calculates the odds of a direct question being asked and backs itself, and the only thing it reliably fails to price is that the question will be asked by someone who already knows. He had six weeks in which the truth remained cheap and he spent them hoping. The police found nothing to answer for; his own answer was the offence.

Source: The Law Society Gazette (reporting the SRA decision notice)

The Wire

The Regulator Closed His Complaint Without Asking the Solicitor a Single Question. It Agreed to Read the Complaint Properly Only After He Threatened It With the High Court. Its Quality Control, It Explained, Is a Monthly Dip Sample.

A regulator that reads your complaint attentively only when you can afford to sue it has not built a complaints process; it has built a toll road. Note what was conceded — not that the decision was wrong, but that the report had been read as narrower than it was, which is the institutional way of saying nobody finished the page. The monthly dip sample is the detail to keep. Somewhere a percentage is calculated, and it is reported upwards, and it is almost certainly reassuring.

Source: Legal Futures

The Wire

They Abolished the Test That Measured Whether Applicants Could Do the Mathematics. Five Years On, Nearly One Freshman in Five Is Failing Introductory Mathematics, and Professors Are Spending Office Hours on Fractions.

A modern classroom and office building on the University of California, Merced campus, the campus with the highest introductory-mathematics failure rate.
Dr vulpes / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0

The instrument was removed because its readings were unwelcome, and the readings turned out to belong to the world rather than to the instrument. Nothing about the students changed; only the moment at which anyone found out. A university is an institution whose entire function is to know things, and this one arranged not to know the one fact that determined whether it could perform that function, then discovered it anyway at the slowest and most expensive point available — in the second semester, one weeping nineteen-year-old at a time. The fractions were always going to turn up. Only the invoice was deferred.

Source: The College Fix (reporting EdSource figures)

The Wire

A Judicial Working Group Was Told the Top Band of Official Hourly Rates Was Too Low for Top-Flight Work. Three Years On It Cannot Set a Higher One, Because No One Will Say What They Actually Charge.

The profession's position is that the official ceiling is insultingly beneath it, and also that what it charges is nobody's business, and it has held both for three years without visible strain. Observe the structure: a body of judges asks the market to prove it deserves more money, and the market declines to answer on the grounds of commercial sensitivity, and so the ceiling stays where everybody agrees it should not be. Every participant is behaving rationally. The result is that the only figure anyone will state out loud is the one they all consider wrong.

Source: Legal Futures (reporting the Civil Justice Council consultation)

The Wire

The Corporation Disconnects Your Water the Moment You Fall Behind. The High Court Pointed Out That It Has Shown No Comparable Urgency About the Footpaths, and That Its Counsel Appeared to Be Banking on the Case Not Being Listed for a While.

The red-brick Indo-Saracenic domes and towers of the Madras High Court building in Chennai.
Sameer.udt / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 3.0

The complaint is not that the body is slow. It is that the body is fast in precisely one direction, which means the slowness elsewhere is a choice rather than a capacity. The sharper finding is the second one: counsel had worked out that a crowded list is a form of immunity, and were litigating the calendar rather than the case. That is not negligence, it is strategy — and it is the strategy of men who have concluded that the court is a weather system to be waited out. The bench has now written down that it noticed.

Source: LiveLaw (reporting the Madras High Court order)

Black-Robed Egomania

The Mandatory Training That Teaches a Justice of the Peace How to Be a Justice of the Peace Was Completed by One of His Own Court Employees, Whom He Ordered to Do It and to Certify That He Had Done It Himself.

A man who sits in judgment on other people's shortcuts could not be troubled to attend the course that explains why. The elegance is in the certification: it was not enough to skip the training, somebody had to sign that he had not. Every justice of the peace in Texas sat through those hours; he alone concluded that the robe had already conferred whatever the hours were for. The fine was $2,290. The course was free.

Source: Texas State Commission on Judicial Conduct, In re Puckett (voluntary agreement to resign in lieu of disciplinary action, 24 September 2026)

LazyTown

He Won His Unfair Dismissal Case. Then He Spent Sixteen Months Not Looking for Work, Re-Roofing His Girlfriend's Four Beauty Salons Instead. Told to Produce His Job Applications, He Suggested His Emails Might Not Have Been Saved. The Commission Subpoenaed SEEK.

The remedy was a job application, which costs nothing and takes four minutes, and he declined to make one for eleven months at a running price of roughly three thousand dollars a week. Note that he was not hiding: he told the Commission he was busy with the guttering, and he said it to the tribunal that was about to set his compensation. The lie came later and was the lazier act of the two — he could not even be bothered to invent a plausible reason the applications were missing, so he suggested the internet had mislaid them. SEEK was asked. SEEK remembered.

Source: HRD Australia (reporting Kacy Brazier v OS MCAP Pty Ltd [2026] FWC 4043)

From the library — 27 special editions

Florida Man: A Field Guide to the GenusNotes toward a natural history of the Sunshine State's most resilient predator — himself. More Scandalous Authors: Mad, Bad, and Dangerous to Read, Vol. IIThe private conduct of literature's great names, continued — the debtors, deserters, duelists, and one… When Settled Science Was Wrong: Eight Confident CatastrophesThe expert consensus of its day — confident, credentialed, peer-approved, and catastrophically wrong.

Browse all special editions →

Daily misanthropy by email — free.
The day's worst decisions, curated every morning, in your inbox by breakfast.

No algorithms. No engagement bait. Just the view from the abyss.

Today's edition  ·  Special editions  ·  Archive  ·  Submit a tip